Public security in the pre-classical political and legal thought of ancient Greece
Abstract
A thorough theoretical and legal study of the key features of general philosophical and special legal understanding and interpretation of security issues of man, society and state in the pre-classical political and legal thought of ancient Greece is given. An analysis of the views of ancient Greek authors (poets, philosophers, historians, lawyers) who are representatives of socio-philosophical and political legal thought of the period against the background of widespread collective ideas about security as a state of social relations, the condition of human (social) life and / or unique social value, objects (spheres) of this security, as well as subjects and regulatory mechanisms to ensure the appropriate state of society and the state is presented.
It is proved that the ancient political and legal doctrines, which comprehend public safety, have the following main features: its nationalization (elevation of the state and its institutions in guaranteeing this security), personalization (close dependence of personal security on public, sometimes even raising personal security over public), universalization (security as a phenomenon of the space world order, general Hellenic security), rationalization (discursive understanding of public security issues), legalization (transfer of public security issues to the plane of its legal support, which becomes imperative, mandatory compliance with polis laws, a system of severe penalties for offenses in the field of public safety, law and order in society and the state), indefiniteness of the actual state and public security (which was due to the polis nature of the state system), axiologization (security as a high human and social value, as a good, as an integral element of the polis worldview and ensuring the proper organization of polis life), polymorphism (breadth of spectrum of public security and specification of its “images” in philosophy, poetry, historiography, rhetoric, etc.).
It is concluded that for the vast majority of ancient Greek thinkers, security issues were related to the phenomenon of harmony between the universe, society and humanity itself. An important source of knowledge about security was considered to be the thoughts of ancient Greek philosophers about proper life and ways to achieve it. For most authors of the time, the main determinants of security were hatred, war and struggle, power and strength. Instead, they associated security with love, peace, and stability, or with a conscious refusal to use violence. For other philosophers, security was a concept of social cooperation (harmony, peace) and integration. Among the ancient Greek authors there were those who put public security in both planes at the same time, looking for its source in a kind of dialectical combination of hatred and love, war and peace, power and stability.
Downloads
References
Andreev, Yu. V. (1998). The price of freedom and harmony. The science.
Antiseri, D., & Reale, J. (2003). Western philosophy from its origins to the present day. Antiquity and the Middle Ages (S. A. Maltseva, Ed.). Pnevma.
Apresyan, R. G. (2013). Achilles’ moral change. The origins of morality in archaic society (based on the Homeric epic). Alfa-M.
Asmus, V. F. (1999). Ancient philosophy. Higher school.
Berger, A. K. (1966). Political thought of ancient Greek democracy. The sciences.
Berman, G. J. (1998). Western tradition of law: the era of formation (N. R. Nikonova, N. N. Deev, Trans.). MGU Publishing House.
Bohutskyi, P. P. (2020). Theoretical foundations of the formation and development of national security law of Ukraine [Doctoral dissertation, Research Institute of Informatics and Law of the National Academy of Legal Sciences of Ukraine].
Brovkin, V. V. (2019). Ancient philosophy and political development of Greece in the period of early Hellenism [Candidate dissertation, Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences].
Drach, G. V. (2003). The birth of ancient philosophy and the beginning of anthropological problems. Gardariki.
Fukidid. (1999). History (Vol. 2) (F. G. Mishchenko, Trans.). The Science.
Gasparov, M. L. (2000). Entertaining Greece: Stories about ancient Greek culture. New Literary Review.
Geraklit. (1999). Fragment. Presocratics (A. Makovelskii, Trans & Ed.). Harvest.
Golubtsova, E. S. (Ed.) et al. (1989). History of Europe (Vol. 1). The sciences.
Gomer. (1967). Iliad. Odyssey (N. I. Gnedych, V. A. Zhukovskii, Transl.). Fiction.
Gould, J. (1973). Hiketeia. The Journal of Hellenic Studies, 93, 74-103. https://doi.org/10.2307/631455.
Hesiod. (2006). Works and days. Ancient literature. Greece. Rome. Reader (T. V. Mykhed, Yu. V. Yakubina, Compilers). Center for Educational Literature.
Hotsuliak, Y., & Opolska, N. (2018). The Image of Themis in Ancient Legal Consciousness. Warmia Studies, 55, 265-278.
Kalnoi, I. I. (2006). Philosophy of law. Legal Center Press.
Keohane, R. O. (1986). Realism, Neorealism and the Study of World Politics. Neorealism and Its Critics. Columbia University Press.
Koziubra, M. I. (Ed.). (2015). General theory of law. Waite.
Lure, S. Ya. (1970). Democritus. Texts. Translation. Research. Leningrad branch of the Sciences publishing house.
Nersesyants, V. S. (2004). History of legal and political doctrines. Norma.
Passakou, P. (2020). The concept of security in Ancient Greece: An analysis through ancient Greek intellectuals. Security Science Journal, 1(2), 90-96.
Plutarkh. (1983). Works (S. Averintseva, A. Loseva, A. Stolyarova, Trans. and Ed.). Fiction.
Rozhanskii, I. D. (Ed.). (1989). Fragments of early Greek philosophers (1989). Part 1. From epic theocosmogony to the emergence of atomism. The Science.
Sharnina, A. B. (2017). Diplomatic tools in the practice of preventing military conflicts in the Hellenistic era: Asylia. Metamorphoses of History, 9, 76-92.
Solon. (1999). Against unity. Hellenic poets of the 8th – 3rd centuries. BC. Epos. Elegy. Yambs. Melika (M. L. Gasparov, Ed.). Ladomir.
Strabon. (1964). Geography (G. A. Stratanovskii, Trans., S. L. Utchenko, Ed.). The Science.
Sydorchuk, O. H. (2018). Social security: state regulation and organizational and economic support. LRIDU NADU.
Volkova, S. V. (1998). Ancient Greek polis (ideas, reality, V-IV centuries BC) [Candidate dissertation, St. Petersburg State University].
Zahumenna, Yu. O. (2021). Public security in classical ancient Greek political and legal thought (teachings of Socrates, Plato, Aristotle). ScienceRise: Juridical Science, 4(18), 15-22. https://doi.org/10.15587/2523-4153.2021.249316.
Copyright (c) 2022 Y. O. Zahumenna
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
